Police and fire

  • Crime reports
    Sector 112/28:53 p.m.Robbery1500 N. Wells St.
  • crime stoppers
    Active warrantsThe Allen County Sheriff’s Department is looking for these people in connection with felony warrants active as of Feb. 6. People with information about the suspects’ whereabouts can call Crime Stoppers.
  • Teacher suspended for pointed lesson
    A teacher at Woodside Middle School has been suspended after displaying a knife during a lesson on the French and Indian War, according to the Allen County Sheriff’s Department.
Advertisement
Area homicides
Adams County
When: Sept. 20
Where: 234 N. Second St., Decatur
What happened: Police believe Jose Soto, 32, stabbed Louis Eguia, 41, multiple times in the chest with a pocket knife after an alcohol-fueled argument at the apartment. When officers arrived, they found Eguia bleeding heavily on the sidewalk outside. He was taken to the hospital, where he died of a stab wound to his heart. Officers arrested Soto hours later. He has been charged with aggravated battery and murder.
DeKalb County
When: May 15
Where: Walker/Rowe Airport, 4529 U.S. 6, Waterloo
What happened: A customer found Raymond Edward Morrow, 63, shot dead inside his flea market at the airport. Less than two weeks later, police filed murder charges against Jeffery W. Cain, 52, of St. Cloud, Fla., Clint D. Hess, 40, of Corunna; Matthew W. Nelson, 28, of Orland; and Matthu R. Sanders, 28, of Hudson.
Detectives believe the four men had plotted to rob and kill the businessman over a $4,000 debt Hess owed him. Court documents allege that Cain, who was visiting from Florida, gunned down Morrow and stole several handguns from his store, and the other three men aided him and helped hatch the plan.
Huntington County
When: April 9
Where: 15 Duke Blvd., Castle Hill Mobile Home Park, Roanoke
What happened: The Roanoke marshal found Nicole Scheiber, 25, and her boyfriend, Jeremy Stroh, 26, dead when he went to their mobile home to check on them. Police believe Stroh shot Scheiber multiple times after an argument and then turned the gun on himself.
Kosciusko County
When: Aug. 15
Where: EMS 18 Lane just north of Defreese Road near Dewart Lake, Syracuse
What happened: According to police, Marc Greene, 41, of Mentone, struck Bradley Wetzel, 40, of Syracuse, with his pickup truck after an argument. Family members said the former best friends had a falling out when Wetzel got into a relationship with Greene’s wife. Wetzel was taken to a hospital, where he died of his injuries. Sheriff’s deputies arrested Greene on a murder charge.
LaGrange County
When: May 9
Where: 203 W. Central Ave., LaGrange
What happened: Cory A. Waltmire, 25, admitted to shooting and killing Jason Smith, 26, and Shaun A. Zimmerman, 25, after they beat and threatened him with a knife at an Angola junkyard over marijuana Waltmire had stolen from them, according to police. Waltmire took the two men to his house in LaGrange, where he retrieved a gun and shot them. Zimmerman died in the house, and Smith was flown to a Fort Wayne hospital, where he later died.
First charged with two counts of voluntary manslaughter, Waltmire pleaded guilty in December to a lesser charge – two counts of reckless homicide.
Steuben County
When: Dec. 18
Where: 945 Fox Lake Road, Angola
What happened: Norma Mote, 45, called police to her house and told them she had just killed her husband, Kevin Mote, 56, with an ax. When police arrived, they found him dead in an upstairs bedroom. The couple’s two teenage sons were home at the time of the killing. Officers arrested Mote on a charge of murder.
Wabash County
When: June 10
Where: 178 W. Dora Road, Wabash
What happened: Investigators believe Tony Rickets, 33, stabbed his ex-girlfriend, Amanda Hines, 27, and her mother, Sherry Hines, 57, to death inside Amanda Hines’ home. When police arrived at the house, they found both women dead and Rickets with a self-inflicted stab wound to the chest. He was taken to the hospital, where he later died.
When: July 2
Where: 5500 block of East Wabash County Road 800 South, La Fontaine
What happened: Lisa Pattison, 36, died in Grant County as her husband was driving her to Marion General Hospital in Marion. Her husband, Scott Pattison, 39, told police his wife accidentally dropped a weight bar across her throat. However, a Wabash County grand jury found there was enough evidence that Pattison killed his wife to indict him for murder.
Wells County
When: Oct. 27
Where: 649 E. Wells County Road 100 S., Bluffton
What happened: Police believe Amy White, 28, and Tyler White, 28, were exchanging custody of their 1-year-old son when Tyler White shot his wife twice in the chest. The couple was going through a divorce, and Tyler White told detectives his wife pointed a handgun at him first. Amy White died at the scene. Her husband is charged with murder.
When: Oct. 28
Where: Wells County roads 800 North and 100 West, Uniondale
What happened: Four Adams County residents ambushed Justin Sprow, 19, as he was driving in northern Wells County and fired several shotgun slugs into his car, killing him, police say. Sprow had argued with one of the men over a bad drug deal moments before the shooting, and the four were planning to rob him, according to court documents.
Police arrested Dustin Jackson, 22, Cody Barkley, 19, Jonathan Thatcher, 19, and Cody A. Mendez, 17, and charged them with murder, murder during the commission of a felony, and conspiracy to commit robbery resulting in serious injury.
Whitley County
When: Nov. 17 or 18
Where: 4041 W. Old Trail Road, Columbia City
What happened: Police searched for nearly a month for the body of Debra Houser, 49, after an informant told police her ex-husband, Rodney Houser, 43, had killed her after an argument at her house and had asked for help hiding the body, according to the Whitley County Sheriff’s Department.
After nearly a month of searching, including a massive manhunt with volunteers, helicopters and planes, detectives found Debra Houser’s body in a creek near her home Dec. 15.
Rodney Houser has been charged with murder.

Area’s small-town slayings easier to solve

Louis Eguia was stabbed to death during an argument in Decatur. Bradley Wetzel was hit by a pickup truck and crushed outside Syracuse. And Kevin Mote was struck in the head and face numerous times with a long-handled, double-bit ax at his home just outside Angola.

Their deaths were three of at least 13 homicides that northeast Indiana, outside of Allen County, saw in 2009. Only Noble County made it through the year without at least one homicide.

In 37 years of law enforcement, Wells County Sheriff Bob Frantz is fond of saying, he’s worked no more than five homicides. But two of those occurred within 48 hours last year.

Trying to find a common thread among the killings is nearly impossible, authorities said.

Most occurred in rural areas of the counties, outside city or town limits.

Other than that, the deaths were dramatically different, as were the outcomes.

Police have made arrests or otherwise solved each case, and the suspects are making their way through the justice system.

Rural homicides are usually easier to piece together than crimes such as street shootings that Fort Wayne police detectives must solve, said 1st Sgt. Mark Carunchia, the head of investigations for the Indiana State Police post in Fort Wayne.

“Everybody knows everybody, and they’re not afraid to talk about it,” he said about investigations in smaller communities.

And the connections between all the players in a rural homicide are usually pretty easy to make, Carunchia said.

In most of the 2009 killings, the suspect was at the scene when police arrived. In two cases, the killer committed suicide.

Another asset has been increased cooperation among police agencies, Carunchia said.

After Raymond Morrow, 63, was found shot to death inside his shop outside Waterloo on May 15, police had no suspects and asked for the public’s help.

A break came three days after the killing when sheriff’s deputies went to 28-year-old Matthew W. Nelson’s home looking for 28-year-old Matthu Sanders on an unrelated arrest warrant. When they searched the home, they found two revolvers, one of which matched the description of a weapon stolen from Morrow’s shop, according to court documents.

The deputies contacted Indiana State Police Detective Mark Heffelfinger, who used the evidence to tie four suspects, including Nelson and Sanders, to the killing. All of them face murder charges.

“You have to be able to recognize an opportunity and act on it,” Carunchia said.

mzennie@jg.net