WASHINGTON – Even under a thin, black shroud, the lines of a vintage 68 Volkswagen Beetle were unmistakable.
And when the cloth came off, at a bizarre unveiling ceremony at the National Museum of Crime & Punishment recently, it took work to be surprised by what was underneath it: an unprepossessing tan Beetle, with a sunroof, looking a little worse for wear with touches of rust, fading paint and a few missing pieces of metal trim.
The tires looked as if they still had a few thousand good miles in them. Inside the cab, the interior had that quintessential old Bug smell – like burning latex – as if the rubber flooring was always smoking a little from the heat underneath.
But this wasnt any Beetle. This was Ted Bundys Beetle, the car into which he lured his victims and in which he killed many of them during a terrifying serial killing spree in the 1970s.
This was kind of like a death wagon, said Wyndell Watkins, a retired D.C. police deputy chief, who was on hand to help introduce the latest iconic celebrity murder object joining Washingtons museum collections.
The car has been stored in a private collection owned by New York-based Arthur Nash, who owns many of the most grisly objects on display in the museums main exhibition. Also from the Nash collection: clown and serial killer John Wayne Gacys painters box, on display in a room dealing with the unseemly murderabilia trade.
Compared with the D.C. snipers car, on display at the Newseum, Bundys VW has the edge of authenticity. The snipers car is a mockup, used at trial, not the actual vehicle from which John Allen Muhammad and Lee Boyd Malvo hunted their victims.
The Bundy car, with a brittle and faded 1976 Utah vehicle inspection sticker (No. 264924) still stuck to its dirty and cracked windshield, was not just the site of murder, but part of the strange all-American charm and innocence that helped Bundy coerce women to get fatally close to him.
But it doesnt belong in a museum. Which is why the Feb. 18 unveiling included some weirdly incongruous preaching from museum officials and others gathered to mark its unnecessary display before a bored and jaded public.
We want to use it as a safety precaution, said Janine Vaccarello, chief operating officer of the privately owned museum (its partners include John Walsh, host of TVs Americas Most Wanted).
The museum, which opened in May 2008, announced the unveiling with a news release headlined: Ted Bundy VW Beetle Serves as New Teaching Tool.
We dont recommend hitchhiking to anyone, echoed Watkins, who summed up the cars didactic power this way: This car represents a warning sign that you have to be careful.
Educational value?
The warnings and putative lessons seem oddly insubstantial compared with the lurid fascination of the car, as if the moral of the Titanic saga is dress warm and always wear a life preserver. But these lessons are absolutely essential to the display of Bundys car, because without them, it is almost indistinguishable from the murderabilia racket.
Curiously, if you pay the $12 to $20 it costs to get into the main exhibition space of the museum, youll find a relatively well-presented panel documenting the murderabilia trade, the buying and selling of objects directly connected to infamous crimes.
Objects associated with Bundy have always been hot in the trade, including a hubcap from Bundys VW that was reportedly offered for sale for a starting bid of $3,500 in 2007.
The museum does a fair job of explaining the passionate debate about this strange economy of artifacts that enrages families of murder victims even as it thrives on the Internet. Is it an ugly, final exploitation of the victims and families? Or a long-standing, morally neutral trade in objects that have always exerted a dark fascination?
But no matter what you think of the murderabilia trade – it has probably done less harm than trade in complex derivatives – its very difficult to distinguish making a profit selling murderabilia from making a profit displaying murderabilia.
The museum has leased Bundys car from Nash, and although one can see it for free in the lobby of the museum, it is a lure to sell tickets, and it is hardly the only object in the museum that qualifies as murderabilia. But, of course, by being on display in a museum, murderabilia objects are magically transformed from suspect status into museum pieces with the power to teach.
Thats a sleight of hand; the supposed academic or didactic value of many pieces on display is an obvious fiction. But when your kids are sick of looking at old Cezannes for free at the National Gallery of Art, of course its tempting to silence their complaints and continue their education with a pilgrimage to the Bundy car.
A sharp and public rebuke from serious museum professionals would be salutary: It would help the public make clearer distinctions between serious museums and the rapidly evolving world of commercial museum-entertainment attractions.
It would force a serious dialogue about the educational value of displaying objects purely for their iconic status, a form of intellectual laziness that afflicts the Smithsonian as much as the crime museum.