You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Learning Curve

  • Campaign Watch
    Indiana Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Bennett's latest large contribution report is for a $25,000 contribution from hedge-fund operator Daniel S.
  • Warm reception for this Statehouse rally
    A raucous throng of protesters descended on the Indiana Statehouse today. Angry labor union representatives still enraged by the right to work law?
  • Campaign watch
    Indiana Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Bennett filed a large contribution report (required for contributions over $1,000) last week showing a $10,000 campaign contribution from Robert L. Luddy of Raleigh, N.
Advertisement

No truce with public education

Gov. Mitch Daniels' remarks to the Weekly Standard about a truce on social issues captured most of the attention, but his comments on education are just as interesting.

No real surprises here but the governor's choice of words seems to be tailored for the audience. The writer, of course, does his best to characterize Hoosiers as complete rubes. Describing a couple of roofers the governor talked up in an Indianapolis-area McDonalds, Andrew Ferguson writes, "They were extremely genial and had no more than a dozen teeth between them."

Ferguson attempted to flatter the governor by complimenting Indiana schools, describing those he had seen with "immaculate athletic fields, vast cafeterias, swimming pools."

"Yeah, it's a problem," is the governor's reply.

"When we were first campaigning, I started to notice, we'd drive through these rural counties, these very poor counties, and we'd drive up over a hill and on the other side you'd see a brand-new high school that looked like Frank Lloyd Wright had just been there. Enormous gold-plated buildings. It turned out we had higher capital expenditures for educational construction per square foot than any other state. There'd be a bond issue and then the architects and contractors would run amok, spending money on things that had nothing to do with academics. I understand why it happens. The school board likes it because they get to play designer for a year. But we couldn't afford it."

If anyone can point me to a "poor" county with a gold-plated school, I would like to see it. The Indy suburbs don't qualify, even if their school buildings are quite nice.

But the governor was just getting started.

"Only 61 cents of every education dollar gets into the classroom in Indiana," he tells Ferguson, who goes on to breathlessly report that "school funding increased every year under Daniels before the recession, and since the downturn, when most areas of state government have seen cuts of 25 percent or more, education has been reduced by only 2 percent.

"Yet the local school boards and their Democratic allies in the state legislature continue to complain. Daniels calls education funding the bloody shirt' of Indiana politics: 'It doesn't take long before somebody starts waving it.' "

The writer describes another restaurant encounter with the common folk :

"We were having lunch one day at a favorite spot, the St. Louis Street Soda Shop in Vincennes, on the Wabash River. Having resisted the Fried Bologna Sandwich ($3.49, with chips, pickle extra), Daniels was washing down a quarter-pound Coney Island dog with a large butterscotch milkshake — 'the best in the state,' he assured Dolly, the delighted owner — when a reporter from the local radio station appeared. She pressed him on the education budget cuts too. She told him the local school board had just laid off nine teachers and an administrator.

" 'What would you say to those people?' she asked.

"He visibly flinched, just as he had on MitchTV.

" 'I'd say it should have been nine administrators and one teacher. There are 20 things that school board could do before it had to lay off one teacher.' "

I checked the Knox County Community Schools Web site to see just how administrator-heavy the school district might be -- not so much, it appears. The central office staff includes the superintendent, an instructional services director, a Title I coordinator, a gifted and talented program coordinator and a few secretaries. In fact, it doesn't have nine administrators to spare. And the photos suggest the school buildings are not "gold-plated."

The governor manages in the lengthy article to get in another plug for Charles Murray, author of "Real Education" and co-author of "The Bell Curve."

Daniels' most startling comment was on a slightly different topic. He told Ferguson that he would deliver the commencement address at Franklin College the following weekend, where he intended to deliver a counterpoint to President Obama's commencement address call for public service, "in which the president discouraged the pursuit of mere material gain in favor of nonprofit and government work," in the writer's words.

"That strikes me as exactly the wrong message to send to young people," Daniels said. "He's got it completely wrong. Government service -- nonprofits -- all that's fine and necessary. But the host can only stand so many parasites."

There you go -- inspiring words for all of you toiling in the fields of government service and nonprofits.

Karen Francisco, senior editorial writer for The Journal Gazette, has been an Indiana journalist since 1981. She writes frequently about education for The Journal Gazette opinion pages and here, where she looks at the business, politics and science of learning as it relates to northeast Indiana, the state and the nation. She can be reached at 260-461-8206 or by e-mail at kfrancisco@jg.net.