Can fart jokes save the reading souls of boys?
You better hope so.
Boys have lagged behind girls in reading achievement for more than 20 years, but the gender gap now exists in nearly every state and has widened to mammoth proportions – as much as 10 percentage points in some states, according to the Center on Education Policy.
It certainly should set off alarm bells, said the centers director, Jack Jennings. Its a significant separation.
Parents of reluctant readers complain that boys are forced to stick to stuffy required school lists that exclude non-fiction or silly subjects, or have teachers who cater to higher achievers and girls. Theyre hoping books that exploit boys love of bodily functions and gross-out humor can close the gap.
Its like pulling out fingernails. He absolutely does not want to read, said Muscle Shoals, Ala., dad Todd Thompson of his 13-year-old, Hunter. I read constantly growing up. So did his mother. So does his 8-year-old sister, but hes a go-go kid. To him, books are a waste of time.
Growing up in Grand Rapids, Mich., Thompson, 47, loved two things: football and books. His mom encouraged regular trips to the library. His dad inspired him to dig into the Chip Hilton sports novels written by legendary basketball coach Clair Bee.
Thompson and his wife did the same with their reading allergic son. No go. Theyve tried bribing him with new video games. Nope. While theyve never considered doling out cash for reading, other parents unabashedly do.
Some books can be pretty boring, and I just dont feel like reading them, said Hunter, a good student who reads what he has to for school. I think a lot of boys feel like that.
The angst among parents, teachers and librarians has been met by a steady stream of sports and historical non-fiction, potty humor, bloodthirsty vampires and action-packed graphic novels, fantasy and sleuthing.
Butts, farts. Whatever, said Amelia Yunker, a childrens librarian in Farmington Hills, Mich. She hosted a grossology party with slime and an armpit noise demonstration. Just get em reading. Worry about what theyre reading later.
Adding online tie-ins or packaged prizes such as the steady-selling 39 Clues series has publishers meeting young readers halfway.
Patrick Carman has gone a step further with his wicked creepy Skeleton Creek series from Scholastic. The upper-grade books use password-protected websites to alternate book text and quick fixes of shaky, hand-held video. To follow the story, reading and watching online are both required.
Were meeting them halfway, Carman said. Its the idea that these books understand where theyre at.
Farts are Ray Sabinis halfway point for younger kids. The fourth-grade teacher from Miller Place, outside New York City, heard from dozens of grateful parents, teachers and librarians after he self-published his SweetFarts in 2008 under the name Raymond Bean.
The book chronicles a 9-year-old boys multimillion-dollar science fair invention of tablets that can change foul-smelling gas into the culprits scent of choice: summer rose, cotton candy, grape – even pickles, as requested by his little sister. It climbed to No. 3 on Amazon in childrens humor in October on little more than word of mouth and prompted a sequel, Sweet Farts: Rippin it Old-School, to be released next month.
Reaching those reluctant boys, its a challenge I take very, very seriously, and this is what they think is funny, Sabini said. Theres also history in there. Theres science in there, the problem of bullying, but its the humor that gets their attention.
Jon Scieszka, a former teacher and Library of Congress literary ambassador for young peoples lit, has been writing kid books for 20 years. He started Guyreads.com to better connect boys with appealing text and begins his Spaceheadz series (Simon & Schuster) about TV-saturated aliens in September, complete with websites that offer more.
We have to meet them where they are, he said. We need to engage kids in this 21st century world, but it doesnt have to be either-or, the digital world or a book.
Scieszka is not convinced educators know how to hook boys, especially when it comes to required reading.
Boys will read a wide variety of stuff, not just gross-out humor, but stuff they enjoy in large part is stuff thats not seen as legitimate reading in some schools, so theyre already feeling theyre not part of the system.
Grossology shouldnt be underestimated in boyland. Scholastics poop fiction star, Dav Pilkey, and his Captain Underpants graphic series remains immensely popular among both genders. Pilkey is bringing back his fourth-grade narrators minus their superhero Aug. 10 in The Adventures of Ook and Gluk, about two kung-fu lovin caveboys sucked into the future.
In Barrington, Ill., Jennifer Lucas said reading is tough for her 10-year-old son, Sean. She thinks teachers in the lower grades dont fully understand boy energy in the classroom.
Its hard for first- and second-grade boys to sit still and learn things the way girls do, like through songs, she said. I think they want so much out of boys when it comes to reading, and theyre not ready.
Cathy Walker, who teaches fourth grade in Raleigh, N.C., is always looking for ways to engage hard-to-reach boys. She stumbled on Sabinis SweetFarts on Amazon, read it for herself and knew it would be a hit all around.
Its a topic most teachers and parents dont openly discuss, she said. Its a great way for boys to engage in topics that are taboo and because of that, they enjoy them even more.
Best-selling author James Patterson knows from personal experience how hard it can be. Son Jack is a great reader now, at age 12, but that wasnt true when he was younger. He wouldnt sit down with a book, beyond what he had to do in school, Patterson said.
Patterson hunted down quality reads for a user-friendly website, ReadKiddoRead.com and began writing for young people, including the Daniel X alien hunter series that has a new installment out this month.
I think it can turn around for a lot of kids. Parents have to take the responsibility seriously. Schools need to be more practical, meaning they need to understand that reading lists are tremendously important but you have to put books on it that the kids are going to respond to, he said. Reading is such a necessary thing to take you through life.