The voice is what grabs you first. It belongs to our narrator, Frank Mackey, a police detective in Dublin. Heres Frank assessing the guy his ex-wife is dating: (Dermot) cant help looking like he lives life on the edge of a massive belch. Or, succinctly describing the slum neighborhood he was raised in as a hive of old brick and lace curtains and watching eyes. Or, recalling the basis of the bad blood between his parents and those of his long-ago girlfriend: My parents didnt like people with Notions; the Dalys didnt like unemployed alcoholic wasters. Franks voice is so wry, bitter and just plain alive that when I finished Faithful Place and began writing this review, I had to think for a long blank minute about the name of the author. To do that, I first had to remember that Frank was created, not real.
My naïve lapse was a tribute to Tana Frenchs extraordinary gifts, and her name should be writ large on every mystery lovers must-read list. Her first novel, In the Woods, swept up the Edgar, Barry, Macavity and Anthony awards. Faithful Place is the third installment in her ongoing saga about the Dublin Murder Squad, and its breathtaking – an elaborately twisted ballad of class resentments, family burdens, regret and passion. The story alternates between the depressed Ireland of the 1980s and the depressed Ireland of the present day, which means that the countrys all-too-brief era of prosperity has been skipped over altogether. Not that the Celtic Tiger ever prowled much in the inner city environs of Faithful Place, the street on which Frank grew up.
Though his beat is in Dublin, Frank has resolutely kept his distance from Faithful Place for all his adult life. Too many nasty memories, too many jeering choruses of the Irish version of the Bronx cheer: Who do you think you are? But his siblings – two sisters and two brothers – still visit his drunken father and grim mother. As Frank explains: All four of the others still put themselves through the weekly nightmare: Sunday evening with Mammy and Daddy, roast beef and tricolored ice cream and its all fun and games until somebody loses their mind. Frank knows about the ritual because hes in sporadic touch with his sister Jackie, who calls one evening with news that upends his world: Builders have been gutting a derelict tenement on Faithful Place in order to sell the old fireplaces and moldings. Theyve found a decayed suitcase, stuck inside an upstairs fireplace. Soon after, a corpse is unearthed in the tenements basement and identified as Rosie Daly, Franks teenaged love.
Twenty-two years before, Frank and Rosie were supposed to run away to London and get married. Except Rosie never showed up the night of their elopement and Frank always assumed shed had second thoughts and escaped from Faithful Place without him. Now, he realizes, she never made the break at all.
Like every serious mystery thats read its Freud, Faithful Place is suffused with an awareness of the stranglehold the past has on the present. To solve Rosies murder, Frank must re-enter the maze of Faithful Place and ingratiate himself with family and friends he thought hed exorcised long ago. (Given that Frank is a cop, the lack of enthusiasm about the reunion is general.) Heres Franks merciless description of one old mate that should give all you female high school and college reunion-goers pause: Not one of those twenty-two years had been nice to Imelda. ...These days she was what the boys on the squad call a BOBFOC: body off Baywatch, face off Crimewatch. She had kept her figure, but there were pouches under her eyes and her face was covered in wrinkles like knife scars.
More dizzying than the journey through the landscape of the past is Franks psychological trip back into the intense feelings of his youth. Not only does the author write beautifully about Franks adolescent yearnings for Rosie, but French also vividly summons up the ego-stomping suffocation that Frank feels even now in the presence of his family:
My ma is your classic Dublin mammy: five foot nothing of curler-haired, barrel-shaped dont-mess-with-this, fueled by an endless supply of disapproval. The prodigal sons welcome went like this:
Francis, Ma said. Could you not be bothered putting on a decent shirt, even?
By its devastating end, Faithful Place affirms the wisdom of Thomas Wolfes much quoted adage, You cant go home again. But, brilliantly, it also affirms the dark knowledge of every great noir mystery: You cant escape home, either.