Parents are wired with an agenda: Theyre driven to keep their children pointed in the right direction and to make sure theyre always safe.
Teenagers, on the other hand, are wired to defy and rebel against anything that feels like a stranglehold. A wise, safe net feels like ridiculous, clunky chains to them.
So whats a parent to do?
Laurens 17 and her parents are not at all pleased with her choice of boyfriends.
Eddies not good for our daughter, Laurens father, Wade, said.
What would make you feel better about Eddie? I asked.
If Lauren didnt support him financially, he said. She pays for his gas, and when they go somewhere to eat, she always foots the bill. He uses her.
Pained disgust was all over Wades face.
He went on. You know, it all boils down to this: Id feel a whole lot better if he treated her well. He doesnt. And shes always upset.
Colleen, Laurens mother, nodded.
It worries me, she said, flustered. We cant seem to reach her ... she wont listen. Weve tried. Weve even set limits on how much time she can spend with him. But that doesnt work; she just starts sneaking around.
In a separate session, I got Laurens story.
I dont think my parents understand, she said. Eddies not that bad. Theyre not giving him a chance.
As I listened, she unloaded her grievances about her parents. As true of most teenagers, she sees them as too controlling.
I spilled the beans.
I told her about The Agenda.
Your parents are wired with an agenda, Lauren. They cant help themselves.
I gave her a thorough explanation.
But, they want to dictate whos right for me, she said.
What kind of guy is right for you? I asked.
For a few seconds, Lauren just gave me a blank look.
I guess hed be someone who is kind, she said. A guy who goes out of his way to make me feel special.
Does that describe how Eddie is with you? I asked.
Well ... yes. Sort of.
You seem uncertain, I said.
Well, I think maybe I give more in the relationship than he does, she admitted.
She related some incidents but then quickly back-pedaled. Casting Eddie in a bad light made her feel guilty.
Hes had a hard life, she said, I always need to remember that.
To Lauren, Eddies hard life explains why he has difficulty holding down a steady job.
She views his various employers in the same light as her parents: They dont give him a fair chance.
In a separate session with her parents, I explained that their daughter is prone to feel sorry for the underdogs of the world.
They couldnt agree more.
I continued: So if she senses the slightest hint of hostility toward Eddie, she will automatically go to his rescue.
Laurens impulse to defend Eddie distracts her from becoming introspective.
She needs to go inside herself and size up her situation while tuning in to how she really thinks and feels. This includes what she finds objectionable about Eddie.
Quite apart from her parents, she needs to form her own conclusions.
Laurens parents can help her do that by becoming her allies and walking with her.
This means showing her that theyre interested and care about her struggles, instead of being reactive, critical or forceful.
To win her trust, I advised them to look for opportunities.
When shes noticeably upset about Eddie, they can say tenderly: You seem upset.
They should strive for a caring tone that invites Lauren to confide.
They should be consoling and listen without judging, advising or lecturing.
Instead of telling her what shes doing wrong, what she should do instead, or showering her with I-told-you-sos, they should merely listen and convey understanding: How frustrating, I get it, No wonder youre upset. I would be too.
When Laurens expressing her frustrations, her parents can trigger introspection with questions such as these: Sweetie, how do you want Eddie to treat you? What do you really need from Eddie? What do you wish he would understand?
Whether Lauren responds to such questions is unimportant. The purpose of the questions is to give her something to chew on. But they should also be prepared to give some advice if invited to do so.
As Colleen and Wade work to rein in their automatic responses, theyre apt to discover they have more influence – not less.
And the potential for that doubles if Lauren feels understood and senses that her parents are in her corner.