The Rocky Horror Picture Show is a cult classic. So are checkerboard Vans, White Castle hamburgers and Eric B. & Rakims Paid in Full. Theyre the pop culture items that, for whatever reason, have a small but fanatical, dedicated and often weird following.
But when youre talking about ice cream, everyones favorite cult classic – and this weeks underrated ice cream flavor – is Blue Moon, the mysterious flavor no one can identify. Ask fans about the flavor and youll get answers ranging from honeydew-ish to kinda Fruit Loops-y, but the main flavor – which may change depending on the manufacturer – remains a closely guarded secret, which just adds to the allure.
Blue Moon ice cream is made almost exclusively in Michigan, Wisconsin and other northern Midwestern states. So its rare to find it in Indiana, but local ice cream shop Atzs always keeps some on hand. So theres no need to wait for an actual blue moon to give it a try. (And when you do, tell us what flavor it is!)
Where: Atzs Ice Cream Shoppe, 3235 N. Anthony Blvd. and 211 E. Tillman Road.
Cost: 99 cents