Dining Out

  • Great grilled cheese worth trip to Auburn
    When one of my doctors told me I needed to try a great new grilled cheese at the Mad Anthony Auburn Tap House, there was little doubt I was going to.
  • Interesting discoveries at Thai spot
    Its name and its gaudy pink-lettered sign made me wonder whether it was a massage parlor instead of a restaurant.
  • Flanagan’s stock rises with bread
    It is a recipe that Flanagan’s Restaurant and Pub owner John Giokaris learned while attending Ohio State University from 1958 to 1961, and it creates one of the best breads in Fort Wayne.
Advertisement

Search Dining Out

Use the options below to search restaurant reviews by name, star rating, or cuisine.

Restaurant Name Search

Restaurant Rating Search

Select by Cuisine

Archive

Mitchell’s Bar & Grill

Out of a possible five
$

New sports bar hits one out of the park

I have gotten used to it every time I walk into a sports bar – the drab tile floors, basic furniture and walls covered with neon beer signs, cardboard NASCAR or Colts cutouts and other freebies from vendors.

Separating one from the other is sort of like trying to decide which New York politician is creepier, Anthony Weiner or Eliot Spitzer.

So when I tell you that Mitchell’s Bar & Grill in the Marketplace of Canterbury is something different, something more high-end in terms of décor, I mean it.

Modern black iron barstools and chairs sit on a marbled painted floor, painted to match the tabletops. The soft mustard walls are decorated with black-letter stenciled quotes from sports figures, both fictional, “If you ain’t first, you’re last – Ricky Bobby,” and real, “Ability gets you to the top, but it takes character to keep you there – John Wooden.” Flat-screen TVs are everywhere – even a small one above the urinal in the men’s room and a giant one outside overlooking the front patio. An array of gorgeous antique sculptured liquor decanters along shelves near the dark brown ceiling adds a touch of class, too.

The place was also spotless, which is seldom the case at sports bars.

The service followed suit. I was greeted with a smile during both visits by servers adorned in referee outfits, but not the risqué types that some themed sports bars incorporate. Those servers were eager to make suggestions and helpful, asking when I wanted my children’s meals served and whether I needed cups with lids for them.

The food also delivered.

The menu has the standard bar fare with a few interesting additions, and breakfast is available all day. Mitchell’s is located in the spot formerly occupied by Sharon’s Diner, which was known for hearty breakfasts, and owner Todd Smith is the son of the Sharon from Sharon’s Diner, Sharon Adams. So many of her breakfast recipes remain.

The Home Run provided a little taste of everything, including some of the best biscuits and gravy I have had in a while. The half order, which came with two eggs, choice of meat, one pancake and hash browns or home fries, had a dense, softball-sized biscuit covered with thick gravy that was dotted with small pieces of still-tender sausage and a fair amount of black pepper. It was heavy and rich, and the pepper perfectly accented the salty sausage. But beware: The biscuits and gravy are only available until 2 p.m.

The pancake in this combo was also quite dense – not a fluffy airy cake – and was just a little crisp on the outside. I chose the hash browns over the home fries based on my server’s recommendation, and they were perfect.

The Triple Play Platter appetizer also allowed me to taste a variety of items as it included three sliders: sloppy joe, hamburger with grilled onions and pulled pork. The hamburger was OK and the sweet sloppy joe was tasty, but the pork stole the show. It had crispy pieces of bark mixed in and an intense smoky flavor that melded beautifully with the sweet barbecue sauce. The best part of this starter, however, might have been the lightly breaded, sweet onion straws on the side.

The sauces were the highlight of the wings at Mitchell’s. The sauces are made in house, and the most interesting was the Boom Boom, which was a creamy orange sauce with a little sweet heat. The hot sauce, Smith said, is an original recipe from the old Brubaker’s Bar and Grill. It had a nice peppery kick, as did the Caribbean Jerk, which sort of snuck up on me with its heat. All of the wings I tried were crispy, but they were so crispy that the meat was a little overcooked.

The meat in the Philly Fanatic was perfectly cooked. This version of a Philly cheese steak was loaded with moist, tender slices of steak that could not have been improved upon. Buttery strips of onion and pepper and tangy Swiss cheese completed the sandwich, which was served on a soft, fresh sub bun.

I would choose one of the homemade soups over the homemade coleslaw, which was a rather standard sweet, creamy version. But you can’t go wrong with either, given they are homemade. The chicken and wild rice soup had a creamy, almost buttery broth with plenty of dark rice, chunks of grilled chicken and the standard mirepoix. It was perfectly seasoned, and I enjoyed every last bite.

I enjoyed most of my bites at Mitchell’s Bar & Grill and will be back to try more. Given its attention to detail and beautiful décor, I will probably bring the family with me, which isn’t often the case when it comes to sports bars.

Restaurant: Mitchell’s Bar & Grill

Address: 5607 St. Joe Road

Phone: 969-0021

Hours: 11 a.m. to 2 a.m. Monday through Thursday, 8 a.m. to 2 a.m. Friday, Saturday and Sunday

Cuisine: American

Handicapped accessible: Yes

Alcohol: Full bar

Credit cards: Yes

Kid-Friendly: Yes, but 21-and-over only after 10 p.m.

Menu: Triple Play ($7.99), soup ($1.99 cup; $2.99 bowl), Philly Fanatic ($7.99), Home Run breakfast ($8.99), wings ($4.99 for 6; all you can eat $8.99 daily)

Rating breakdown:

Food: **

(3-star maximum);

atmosphere: * (1 maximum), service: * (1 maximum)

Note: Restaurants are categorized by price range: $ (less than $20 for three-course meal), $$ ($20-$29); $$$ ($30-$39), $$$$ ($40-$49), $$$$$ ($50 and up).

Ryan DuVall is a restaurant critic for The Journal Gazette. This review is based on two unannounced visits. The Journal Gazette pays for all meals. E-mail him at rduvall@jg.net, call at 461-8130. DuVall’s past reviews can be found at www.journalgazette.net, and you can hear Ryan from 3 to 4 p.m. every Thursday on 92.3 FM, The Fort.