WASHINGTON – Gregg Schwarz frowned as he positioned himself, just so, in front of the wrought iron fence surrounding John Edgar Hoovers grave, a place he had visited countless times but never before in anger.
A retired FBI agent who joined the agency in 1972, the year Hoover died, Schwarz had hired a videographer to film him for YouTube expressing his displeasure with a movie that depicted Hoover as a repressed homosexual. In a dig at Clint Eastwood, the director of J. Edgar, Schwarz titled his video response, Dirty Harry to Filthy Harry.
Mr. Hoover was portrayed as an individual who had homosexual tendencies and was a tyrannical monster, Schwarz said, as the sun glinted off his FBI cuff links and FBI lapel pin. That is simply not true.
Many former FBI agents share Schwartzs pique with the films dropped hints of an abiding love between Hoover and aide Clyde Tolson, who is buried a few grave sites away. Historians agree that there is no evidence that either man was gay, and a request for comment from either Eastwood or screenwriter Dustin Lance Black was declined.
Since J. Edgars release early last month, hundreds of agents have griped about the film on xgboys, a closed email list for FBI retirees that takes its name from one of Hoovers pet dogs, which in turn is a play on the old nickname for federal agents, G-men.
I dont know anyone whos not extremely upset, said Bill Branon, a former agent who is chairman of the J. Edgar Hoover Foundation, which grants scholarships to college students studying law enforcement and forensics. Its not only because of our admiration for him. Its the fact its just not true. If it were true, it wouldnt be the worst thing in the world. But dont do that to the poor guy when hes dead and gone.
The widespread unhappiness over Hollywoods imagined rendering of Hoovers rumored-but-never-proven personal life largely comes from men who started their FBI careers when Hoover was still in charge. Their devotion is undimmed almost four decades after his death.
Nowhere is that more evident than at Hoovers grave at Congressional Cemetery. The headstone usually has several stones perched atop it, a sign of recent visitors. There are often fresh flowers inside the wrought iron fence that was forged by a former agent turned metalworker. Retired agents periodically tend the grave site, removing weeds and overgrown grass. Some newly minted agents make post-graduation pilgrimages there, even though Hoover is not on the curriculum at the FBI Academy.
Agents younger than 70 or so dont get it, said Brad Benson, president of the Society of Former Special Agents of the FBI.
Devotion is probably a good word for my generation and up, said Benson, 70. The more recent people cant understand why all the energy is being devoted to this when our (retirement) benefits are at stake.
Older agents say their admiration for the late director is cemented in his role in building up the FBI and instituting several law enforcement innovations, such as crime labs and fingerprinting databases. Many cite his thoughtful gestures, the kind that engender loyalty, including the personal notes he sent to mark special occasions in an agents family such as births, deaths and anniversaries.
But mostly, they say, they are offended because the intimation that Hoover was gay is false. They say agents, apparently a gossipy bunch among themselves, would have heard about it if it were true because Hoover was always tailed for his protection, despite his objections; they called it Hoo-Watch.
Its hard to have an illicit homosexual love affair with an agent looking in the back window of your car, said Fred Robinette, a former FBI agent and Hoovers grand-nephew.
John Fox, the FBI historian, said speculation about Hoovers sexuality never got very far. Hoover was single all those years, Fox said. His closest friend and associate was another man. Periodically through the history of his tenure there was an innuendo here, an innuendo there that he was homosexual. But that was the extent of it.
What is known is that gay men were blackballed from the FBI during that era because Hoover considered them vulnerable to blackmail if their sexual orientation were discovered.
He thought people with homosexual tendencies were a security risk, Schwarz said. Everybody knew it at the time. Anybody who thought homosexuality was a security risk would not, and did not, condone that type of activity.
Former agents who were consulted said they told the filmmakers that rumors of Hoovers homosexuality were untrue.
Cartha Deke DeLoach, a former high-ranking FBI official whose office was across the hall from Hoover, said he told that to both Eastwood, who called him for advice, and Leonardo DiCaprio, the actor who played Hoover. In a sit-down meeting, DiCaprio asked DeLoach to help make me Hoover.
He said he didnt think the movie was going to delve into it in great length, DeLoach said of DiCaprio. DeLoach praised both Eastwood and DiCaprio as decent men but added: Its wrong making insinuations (Hoover) was homosexual. I think it was an attempt to gain popularity, and they had to use several insinuations that werent correct.
When Branon, of the J. Edgar Hoover Foundation, started hearing rumors the film would portray a sexual relationship between Hoover and Tolson, he wrote to Eastwood seeking reassurances.
It would be a grave injustice and a monumental distortion to proceed with such a depiction based on a completely unfounded and spurious assertion, said the letter.