You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Editorial columns

  • Rev the small-business engine
    The United States doesn’t need a new economic engine. It already has one: entrepreneurship. It’s just that we aren’t getting the mileage out of it that we could. Small businesses are instrumental to the U.S. economy.
  • Agenda for a stronger Hoosier economy
    Going into the fall election, Hoosier citizens are, and should be, concerned about jobs. If what we hear on the campaign trail is any indication, many are wondering, “What are my state legislators doing to help?
  • U.S. falls short on debt to military vets
    Here is something worth remembering as we celebrate Memorial Day: The Department of Veterans Affairs estimates that every 80 minutes a veteran takes his or her own life.
Advertisement

Gun-carry licenses constitutionally unneeded

The whole subject of states’ handgun carry permits, recognition, reciprocity and pre-emption is a convoluted, confusing and, essentially impossible-to-understand can of worms, with the worms always moving and always changing.

Law-abiding gun owners can easily run afoul of handgun carry laws in other states despite having a valid carry permit in their home state.

For example (and the examples are legion!), a resident of Indiana with the Indiana License to Carry a Handgun who travels into Ohio while in possession of a handgun commits a felony because Ohio refuses to recognize the Indiana carry law.

I am perfectly legal in Fort Wayne, New Haven and Woodburn, but, if I travel a few miles further east, I become a felon simply by crossing the state line into Ohio.

On Nov. 16, the House passed House Resolution 822, The National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act of 2011. Basically, HR 822 says any person possessing a valid handgun carry permit from any state may legally carry a handgun in any other state that permits handgun carry, meaning every state but Illinois.

People carrying handguns would still be subject to all laws of each state where carrying.

As expected, the shopworn chorus of “blood in the streets” was raised by the usual suspects: Rep. Carolyn McCarthy, Sens. Frank Lautenberg and Chuck Schumer, and the Brady Campaign, among others.

In spite of all the predictable hand-wringing, the bill passed by an overwhelming margin of 272-154 with 47 Democrats voting for it and only seven Republicans opposed.

There is no companion bill, yet, in the Senate, and in the unlikely scenario of passage by the Senate, it is even more unlikely it would be signed into law by the current president.

Even some pro-gun people are opposed to HR 822, seeing it as another dangerous abdication of power to a federal government that will corrupt the power and end up using it against law-abiding gun owners. I share that concern.

Enter the concept of what is termed “constitutional carry” or unrestricted carry. Two Supreme Court decisions, Heller and MacDonald, have established the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms is 1) an individual right, and 2) that right applies to all states and federal enclaves.

Vermont has never had nor required a handgun carry permit for its residents. In 2003, Alaska removed the requirement for law-abiding residents to have a permit to carry handguns. In 2011, both Arizona and Wyoming joined the constitutional carry club. Sixteen more states recently introduced constitutional carry legislation.

Leaders in these states are recognizing that law-abiding gun owners are among the people least likely to cause trouble and that the Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms is, indeed, a right and not a privilege subject to permission and licensing by governmental entities.

Criminals, especially violent criminals, are never deterred by licensing laws.

As more states join the 20 current states either having or considering constitutional carry, the need for a federal reciprocity law will diminish and, finally, go away.

Although Indiana already recognizes handgun carry permits of every state that issues them, Indiana lawmakers should take the next logical, common sense and constitutional step: Eliminate the requirement for law-abiding residents to purchase and possess a license to carry.

Bob Aldridge, a Fort Wayne resident, is a National Rifle Association-certified firearms instructor. He wrote this for The Journal Gazette.