Yea, though NBC walks through the valley of the shadow of death, all hope is not lost. Smash, the networks easily engaging new Monday night drama about the making of a Broadway musical, turns out to be quite the little sunbeam. It has some endearing characters, an instinct for backstage meows and a firm grip on its own sense of camp control, which, if nothing else, sets it apart from Ryan Murphys now fully atrocious Glee.
Will Smash pull NBC back from its inexorable slide? Who knows; who cares. In another time and place, Smash would have the assured vibe of a hit. But in this too-smarmy, post-Rent place, Smash too often swoons from an incurable disease known as the theater bug.
Which makes sense because this is a show made by and for people with a lifelong case of Broadways restless leg syndrome. Breaking out into song and dance (with full accompaniment) is just a matter of course here, and whether you think thats wonderful or not depends entirely on your predisposition for spotlights. Smash wont convert anyone to the lifestyle, but it will intrigue those who are already deep in it.
Then again: I hate the theater. I really do, grumbles the moody husband of the shows lead character, Julia, played by Will & Graces Debra Messing. Shes a hit Broadway musical writer, but shes promised her husband and her teen-age son that she will take a year off to focus on adopting a Chinese baby. Then Julia begins having stray thoughts about the myth and meaning of Marilyn Monroe. (Because who doesnt? Everyone from Norman Mailer to the drag queen down the street has tried to deconstruct Norma Jean.)
Soon enough, Julia and her co-writer, Tom (played by Broadway stage vet Christian Borle), are batting about ideas for a big Marilyn musical. Ooh – there could be a number where Joe DiMaggio, Arthur Miller and JFK all sing about what they look for in a woman!
Its all too enticing, except for the fact that its quite possibly a stink bomb. A Marilyn musical? character after character asks with an understandable sneer. One of the neat tricks in the first four episodes is how quickly Smash converts a viewer to the concept of turning Monroes rise to stardom into a boisterous, big-budget show. Theres something about her, Julia says. How much she wanted to love and be loved. She glows with it. She reminds me of a saint.
Sneakily, an opportunistic office assistant (Jaime Cepero) uses his iPhone to upload a video of Julia and Toms nascent effort at a Marilyn ballad, setting the online theater world instantly abuzz with possibility. Its a Spider-Man-style disaster waiting to happen – except everyone wants in. Anjelica Huston gives Smash a welcome lift with her rich performance as Eileen Rand, a big-time producer going through a nasty divorce. Her husband (also a big producer) has taken away Eileens rights to a My Fair Lady revival, and so, having repeatedly thrown cocktails in hubbys face at various Manhattan restaurants, Eileen decides to produce the Marilyn musical on her own – hawking her jewels and a treasured Degas sketch to raise cash.
Against Toms objections, Eileen brings in a talented but megalomaniacal British director, Derek Willis (Jack Davenport), who cautiously reminds Smashs characters (and its audience) that it can take five years to get a musical from workshop to Broadway stage. Nevertheless, Marilyn: The Musical begins a mad dash to casting calls.
Which brings us to Smashs essential business: Who will play Marilyn? Two candidates emerge: Ensemble veteran Ivy (Wickeds Megan Hilty) and Iowa newcomer Karen (American Idols Katharine McPhee, runner-up to Taylor Hicks in 2006). Ivy is everyones obvious choice – a curvy blonde with pipes as big as her ambition – but Karen has a luminescence and small-town innocence that suggests something more transformative than a Marilyn facsimile. McPhee gives the part (Karen and Marilyn) her all but falls somehow short of convincing.
Unconvincing for the role, you mean, or for the TV show? Both. Its a nagging question throughout, as one gets the sneaking suspicion that if Smash is anything like a hit, then Marilyn: The Musical is not far from actuality. Worse things have happened, I suppose, and one of Smashs strongest attributes is its music, with Tony-friendly songs by Marc Shaiman and Scott Wittman (whose credits include Hairspray: The Musical and a whole lot else).
Smash has weaknesses, to be sure: Messings performance makes me think of chenille throws and long naps; the dialogue gets hacky in every episode; the ghost of The Playboy Club sends a chill through the chorus-girl dressing room scenes. But Smash also has a confidence that speaks to its pedigree: Creator Theresa Rebeck is an accomplished playwright and TV producer/writer; the shows other producers and writers have a wealth of stage and screen experience. That expertise makes Smash feel a little more special, enough so that Broadway junkies wont be disappointed by the details.
Theyll also be encouraged to suspend their easily suspended disbelief. Isnt that all a musical ever asks us to do? Forgive the occasional weaknesses in the book and just enjoy the razzmatazz?
Smash is a case where not bad is plenty good enough.