You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Frank Gray

  • Saddle up! Fort4Fitness bicycle event quite a sight
    Last year, the largest bicycle tour in recent memory, if ever, in Fort Wayne attracted nearly 1,000 riders who threaded their way through residential areas of the city, out into the countryside and back into town.
  • 1853 silk banner has another side
    In 1853, somewhere in Fort Wayne, a procession was held celebrating the opening of the first free public school in the city. Fittingly, a schoolboy took part carrying a banner, proclaiming the value of education.
  • Airport caters to business fliers; not all happy
    Steve Staley travels a lot for a living, flying all over the country auditing building inspectors for HUD, whatever that involves.
Advertisement

Smoking ban in homes too far?

Big Brother, it appears, will be coming into your home soon – at least if you live in a property run by the Fort Wayne Housing Authority.

According to a draft letter that will be sent to residents of Housing Authority property, the agency plans to add an addendum to its leases, prohibiting smoking in all its buildings, individual units and grounds, starting Jan. 1.

Residents will be required to sign a copy of the addendum.

Maynard Scales, executive director of the Housing Authority, confirmed that the ban is coming.

“Actually, it’s been three years in the planning,” Scales said.

The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development has been pushing housing authorities all over the country to impose such bans, Scales said. Of the 3,000 or so housing authorities in the country, 50 percent to 60 percent have imposed similar bans, he said.

“The board resisted,” Scales said. “It wanted to give people time to adjust to it. HUD said we must consider it.”

There is a money issue, Scales said. It is more expensive to turn over a property that has been occupied by a smoker. Apartments are painted when residents change, but an apartment that was occupied by a smoker has to get two coats of paint, he said.

The policy isn’t sitting well with some residents.

Gail Surfus is a resident of Whispering Oaks, a relatively new complex on Decatur Road that rents only to people age 62 or older.

“I don’t understand,” Surfus said. “Cigarettes are legal. We’re not doing anything illegal. This is our home, and just because HUD subsidizes the rent (residents have to pay 35 percent of their income in rent) doesn’t mean they can tell us how to live.”

June Otalski doesn’t smoke, but she doesn’t like the policy any more than Surfus. She doesn’t want to sign the addendum because they’re taking away part of her freedom.

“They’re telling you what you can do in your own home,” said Otalski’s daughter, Deb Jones, who doesn’t live with her mother. “You can’t even let family members visit if they smoke.”

Lady Parker, who also lives in the complex, said she smokes but not in her apartment.

“I do it on the porch, and I won’t even be able to do that,” she said.

Surfus also mentioned a woman in her 70s who lives in one of the apartments.

“She’s been smoking all her life. She says it calms her down,” Surfus said. “How is she supposed to quit?”

The addendum refers to the dangers of secondhand smoke, but that argument doesn’t make sense to many residents because they live alone. They’re affecting only themselves. They won’t even be able to smoke in their cars, Surfus said.

Where does it stop, the women asked?

Scales indicated the Housing Authority isn’t going to be heavy-handed about this. If a resident refuses to sign the addendum, when their lease expires they will be approached and told of the policy. If they still refuse to sign it they will be asked to leave, but they will be given time – three or four months – to find another place to live, he said.

One can see the viewpoint of the residents. Yes, their rents are subsidized, but they still pay rent. The apartments are their homes, and we have a government agency telling people how to live their lives.

Granted, landlords have the right to set policies for their properties. They can forbid pets, say they don’t want people smoking in their buildings, forbid loud parties and so on, and charge security deposits.

That’s a bit of power you get when you plunk down the cash and become the owner of an apartment or house.

But when the government steps in, it does begin to look like Big Brother.

Of course, residents who don’t like it can move, but as Surfus explained, “Do you think we’d be living here if we had any money?”

Frank Gray reflects on his and others’ experiences in columns published Sunday, Tuesday and Thursday. He can be reached by phone at 461-8376, by fax at 461-8893, or by email at fgray@jg.net. You can also follow him on Twitter @FrankGrayJG.

Advertisement