JANESVILLE, Wis. – Mitt Romney has made his first presidential-level decision, picking Paul Ryan, the 42-year-old congressman from southern Wisconsin, as his running mate. The choice offers the first real hints about what kind of president Romney would be: He takes risks, he can adapt and hes willing to campaign on a bold set of ideas rather than generalities.
These are all strong qualities. The Ryan pick also tells us less flattering things about Romney: Hes willing to discard once deeply held views about the necessity of business and executive experience and to cosset the GOP base for political reasons at the expense of independents.
The stakes for voters have always been high, but the way the campaign has played out has not matched the claims by both candidates that this is the most important election of a generation.
Romney has had plans he could point to, but he wasnt really running on them. Now hes put a greater emphasis on those plans, which means this election will be a clearer choice for voters. It will touch on the central question of how you refashion government in a time of scarcity and when a majority of the public is scared.
The Ryan pick is thrilling. Thats a first for Romneys campaign. Now conservatives have something to vote for. Ryan is a revered figure in conservative circles. He is an evangelist for the free market and lower taxes, and he doesnt apologize. Over the last few months, there has been an influential chorus of Republicans calling for Romney not only to get specific about conservative solutions but to campaign on them. Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels argued that only by campaigning with brio could Romney win a mandate for governing.
By picking Ryan, Romney has staked his campaign on fundamentally restructuring the government and its relationship to the people who fund it. Ryan has called for the privatization of Social Security and transforming Medicare from a defined benefit plan to a defined contribution plan.
As a conservative ideas man, Ryan is well ahead of most others in his party not just in his level of specificity but in his willingness to stand behind his ideas. But in 2010, Republican leaders didnt embrace Ryans road map, particularly the change to Medicare. House Republicans were running against Democrats by arguing that Democrats were destroying Medicare, something that would have been hard to do while also championing the Ryan plan. Those ideas are now so central to the partys chances of winning the White House that they won Ryan a spot on the ticket.
Ryan is loved by conservatives, but he makes moderate Republicans nervous. Weve switched the campaign from being about jobs and Obamas bad record to one about Paul Ryans Medicare plans, said one Republican strategist, echoing the sentiment of several I interviewed. The Romney team argues that swing-state independents will see the new policy focus as a road out of their current economic woes. Some Republican strategists think its a gift to the Obama campaign.
Thats because one of the Obama teams goals has long been to tie Romney to Ryan and his budget proposals. They also wanted this election to be a choice, not a referendum on Obama. When both the incumbent and the challenger have the same goals, it suggests that one of them really has it very wrong.
Ryan is not a complement to Romney. Hes an injection of energy, like Sarah Palin was for John McCain. He is telegenic and enjoys sparring with those who doubt him, which are important skills. Hes also a possible ambassador to middle class and Rust Belt voters in the way that Vice President Biden has been for Obama. That might put a state like Wisconsin, which was trending toward Obama, back in play.
When Romney talked about his pick before it was announced, he said, in an interview with NBC, that he wanted a candidate who had a vision for the country that adds something to the political discourse about the direction of the country. Sounds good, but the president is the one who is supposed to have the vision. In this case though, the No. 2 has the vision and instincts that Romney doesnt. Its why so many wanted Ryan to run for president.
Romney is certainly capable of articulating a vision. Thats what he did with his health care plan in Massachusetts. But he is reluctant to boast about those achievements.
Perhaps Romney can take a vision graft from Ryan. Hell have to, because voters wont be lured by Ryans ideas unless the man at the top of the ticket makes the case for them.