BRUSSELS – Drinking a Bordeaux wine from a chateau is as French as swigging Kentucky bourbon is American.
But now tempers are flaring across the vineyards of France. The United States wants to sell some of its wines in the European Union with – sacrilege – a chateau or clos label.
Is that cheating? Misappropriation? Whatever it is, the issue has the Bordelais turning claret with anger.
What is at stake is the respect for tradition and quality, Laurent Gapenne of Chateau de Laville and president of the Federation des Grand Vins de Bordeaux told The Associated Press.
For American vintners, its a question of selling more wine in their top export market, unshackled by historic language or restrictive terms in the world of 21st-century globalization.
People use words in different ways, WineAmerica chief operation officer Cary Greene told the AP, arguing there should be no ban on U.S. bottles carrying the word chateau.
But the French argue that hundreds of years of craft are at stake. Theyre worried that the cachet a mention of chateau or clos – which shows the origin of the wine – carries is diluted if other winemakers started to stick it on their bottles in Europe.
EU experts from the different member states were supposed to vote today on the issue, but that was postponed after talks Monday between the EU and French Farm Minister Stephane Le Foll .
I asked my services to clarify all of these matters, EU Agriculture Commissioner Dacian Ciolos said late Monday, effectively ruling out an immediate decision.
Its the latest skirmish in a trans-Atlantic wine war that has seen the United States grow from an upstart to an increasingly confident competitor on world markets.
U.S. founding father Thomas Jefferson was enamored with French wines and the French held dominance over world wine traffic until well after World War II. Then came the 1976 Judgment of Paris, when, to French astonishment, California won a major blind taste test over French wines.
To this day, that event is considered the tasting that changed the wine world. That never sat well with the French, and since then wine relations have often had an edge.
So when the European Commission decided to act on a U.S. request to regain permission to export chateau and clos-labeled wines to Europe – including France – the anger was palpable.
The European Commission is bartering our heritage and our economic clout at the expense of globalization, Gapenne said.
For the U.S., the benefits of tapping the European market are clear. Even though it is declining, the 27-nation European Union still accounts for 57 percent of the global wine consumption.
Last year, 34 percent of U.S. wine exports by value went to the EU, accounting for $478 million. And the industry is counting on removing trade barriers worldwide to push exports even more.
While French chateau bottles find their origins in wines made at the estate from grapes belonging to the chateau, the U.S. definition for export would use less stringent conditions on provenance. It could include grapes from vines that have been traditionally used by this wine producer or producer group.