You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

High Schools

Cathie Rowand | The Journal Gazette
Bishop Dwenger’s Alexa Siegel, left, and Carroll’s Kyley Marano try to gain control of the ball in the second half.

Dwenger uses PKs for KO

Saints score on 2 opportunities to reach final

Photos by Cathie Rowand | The Journal Gazette
Carroll’s Victoria Minnich tries to work the ball toward goal but is guarded by Bishop Dwenger’s Alexa Siegel, middle, and Michelle Adgalanis during the Carroll Sectional semifinals Tuesday.
Carroll’s Olivia Knispel, middle, and Rylie Allen guard Bishop Dwenger’s Kellee O’shaughnessy in the first half. O’shaughnessy tied the score at 1 with just under 13 minutes remaining on a penalty kick.

– Desired or not, penalty kicks were kind to the Bishop Dwenger girls soccer team in the Carroll Sectional semifinals – on two occasions.

The Class 2A No. 16 Saints advanced to Thursday’s sectional championship with a 2-1 win in PKs over No. 9 Carroll on Tuesday.

“We were good enough in the penalty kicks, but you never want to go to penalty kicks,” Dwenger coach Jeff Killion said. “But in this situation, it worked out for us.

“(The Chargers) are a very good team, and we are very fortunate to win.”

Bishop Dwenger (12-4) will face Snider (12-2-1), an 8-1 winner over Northrop in the second semifinal, at 7 p.m. Thursday in the title match.

Carroll (12-3-2) saw its early 1-0 lead disappear in the second half as Kellee O’shaughnessy tied the score at 1 with under 13 minutes remaining on a penalty kick.

“I felt like we outplayed them in regulation, but sometimes the game of soccer works that way,” Carroll coach Rick Smith said. “It shouldn’t come down to PKs, but we should have finished some things we didn’t.”

The PK opportunity resulted after a controversial hand-ball call in the box by the official.

“You have 11 seniors who have worked their butts off, and to have it taken away like that is just not right,” Smith said. “I am not going to get over this one because I feel like it was taken away from them. The kids didn’t get a fair shot.”

The teams played two scoreless overtime sessions before Dwenger won in penalty kicks, 4-3, as senior goalkeeper Kathryn Jenkins stopped an early PK attempt and Carroll had another one go wide to set off a frenzied Saints’ celebration.

“I just love it,” Jenkins said of penalty kicks. “It is like intensity, and you pretty much just have to guess a lot. I am excited, and I love PKs. I don’t get nervous.”

Kyley Marano gave the Chargers a 1-0 lead in the first half when she headed in a goal in heavy traffic on a corner kick with an assist from Claire Geiger.

“We had to push some people up from the sides and push forward a little more and come up as a team and come back as a team,” Jenkins said of rallying to tie the score.

Dwenger rebounded from a 6-1 loss to Homestead late in the regular season.

“It was just something we had to bounce back from,” Jenkins said. “They are probably the best team we have seen.”

Killion, who is in first season as the Saints coach, agreed.

“That was a shocker to these guys to get beat that bad,” he said. “We are not worried about that one, and we put it behind us.”

In the other semifinal, Snider beat Northrop 8-1 behind four goals and two assists from freshman Mikayla Unger.