OKLAHOMA CITY – Nearly three dozen states – including Indiana – have failed to meet conditions of a 2006 federal law that requires them to join a nationwide program to track sex offenders, including five states that have given up on the effort because of persistent doubts about how it works and how much it costs.
The states, including some of the nations largest, stand to lose millions of dollars in government grants for law enforcement, but some have concluded that honoring the law would be far more expensive than simply living without the money.
The requirements would have been a huge expense, said Doris Smith, who oversees grant programs at the Arkansas Department of Finance and Administration. Lawmakers werent willing to spend that much, even though the state will lose $226,000.
The Adam Walsh Child Protection and Safety Act, named after a boy abducted from a Florida mall and killed in 1981, was supposed to create a uniform system for registering and tracking sex offenders that would link all 50 states, plus U.S. territories and tribal lands.
When President George W. Bush signed it into law, many states quickly realized they would have to overhaul their sex offender registration systems to comply.
Some lawmakers determined that the program would cost more to implement than to ignore. Others resisted the burden it placed on offenders, especially certain juveniles who would have to be registered for life. In Arizona, for instance, offenders convicted as juveniles can petition for removal after rehabilitation.
The deadline to comply with the law was July 2011. Thirty-four states have still been unable to meet the full requirements, and five of those have decided they wont even try. Arizona, Arkansas, California, Nebraska and Texas will instead forfeit 10 percent of the law-enforcement funding made available through the Justice Department.
In Texas, a Senate committee conducted two years of hearings and recommended that the state disregard the law, citing concerns about juvenile offenders and other new mandates. The committees report acknowledged the loss of an estimated $1.4 million.
But that figure paled when compared with the cost to implement the changes, which could have exceeded $38 million.
The Arizona legislature drew a similar conclusion, rejecting the law in 2009 after a committee determined it would cost about $2 million to fulfill all requirements – far more than the estimated $146,700 in grants that would be withdrawn.
California, the nations most populous state, risked losing nearly $800,000 in funding this year, but a 2008 estimate put the cost of complying at $32 million, officials said.
The five states that have given up on the program still have the option to reapply for the withheld money.
The 29 states that are in partial compliance have asked to have their withheld money released to help them meet conditions of the law.
Richard Kishur, an Oklahoma City counselor who has worked with sex offenders for more than 30 years, said his biggest reservation was that the law categorized offenders by the crime they commit, not the risk they actually pose.
What we need to do is be rational about it and apply resources to people who are dangerous and quit wasting our money and time on people who arent dangerous, Kishur said.
Proponents of the law had hoped it would ease the risk that states with less-stringent registration would become havens for sex offenders.
Mark Pursley, who managed sex offenders for nearly a decade at the Oklahoma Department of Corrections, recalled hearing offenders discuss moving to states with relaxed rules.
They were very in tune with what requirements were in different states, and they would frequently migrate to other states, Pursley said.
James Womack, a convicted sex offender from Oklahoma who now works for a nonprofit agency that helps recently released felons, cautioned that registration alone will not stop them from re-offending.
It doesnt do anything to stop crime. A true pedophile, if theyre going to offend, theyre going to offend, whether or not they live one mile or 10 miles from a school, he said.