You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Editorial columns

  • Public school backers deserve your backing
    Elections in Indiana are critically important and represent the most fundamental decision-making authority of a representative government. Elections choose our leadership and guide our state’s future.
  • $2 billion surplus is goal, no matter the cost
    Shortly after the close of the fiscal year last June 30, our governor and auditor glowingly reported that our state had a budget surplus of more than $2 billion. How were we able to achieve this?
  • Literacy an investment with lifelong benefits
    September is Literacy Month, a chance to raise awareness about low adult literacy.
Advertisement

FISCAL CLIFF

Five myths about the

At the end of the year, the country faces an abrupt series of broad tax increases and blunt cuts to most federal programs unless Congress and the White House act. Most policies that have set up the fiscal cliff were never really intended to take effect. Some were designed to try to nudge lawmakers to find longer-term solutions to reduce the nation’s unsustainable deficits. Let’s set the record straight about what the fiscal cliff is – and how we can avoid it.

1. The fiscal cliff is mainly about defense cuts and the expiration of the Bush tax cuts.

A good amount of the attention that the fiscal cliff receives focuses on defense cuts or the expiration of the George W. Bush-era tax cuts (which President Obama renewed in 2010). These do make up a large portion of the fiscal cliff: more than $500 billion in defense cuts and more than $2.7 trillion in tax increases over the next 10 years. But they’re just the beginning.

If lawmakers do not patch the alternative minimum tax, that tax threshold, which applies to 4 million people today, could ensnare nearly 30 million people, raising their tax bills by an average of $2,700. Additionally, non-defense discretionary cuts would hit programs for low-income people such as housing and energy assistance. And more than 2 million people would lose federal unemployment benefits.

Additionally, going over the fiscal cliff would likely lead to a recession, causing further job losses.

2. It’s OK to punt for another year.

Some have called on lawmakers to postpone parts of the fiscal cliff by waiving the budget sequester or extending the tax cuts without offsetting the costs. As the end of the year inches closer, calls are likely to increase.

But making either of these moves without putting in place the beginnings of a deficit-reduction plan would send a dangerous signal to global markets, businesses and the American public that Washington is not serious about fiscal responsibility and, frankly, can’t govern.

Moody’s, Standard & Poor’s, and Fitch Ratings have said that the United States could lose its AAA credit rating – or face further downgrades in the case of S&P – if steps are not taken to reduce the debt. Such a downgrade could harm economic confidence and growth down the road.

Furthermore, the threat of the fiscal cliff is the only thing propelling policymakers to work out a larger deal.

3. Going over the fiscal cliff wouldn’t immediately damage the economy.

Some experts have argued that going over the cliff wouldn’t cause much immediate economic harm and that any damage could quickly be reversed by retroactively waiving the tax increases and spending cuts. That’s like saying: “Don’t worry about being run over – the car will be off you shortly.” In most cases, the damage is already done.

There is no way to know how the economy and the markets would react to our going over the fiscal cliff, but we should not be willing to find out. As Alan Kreuger, chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers, said, there would be a serious psychological effect as well, leading people to think “that government is not capable of solving problems that it’s there to solve.”

Thus far, the markets still believe that policymakers would not be so foolish as to willingly cliff-dive – but the moment they are proved wrong, the markets could go into an expensive tailspin.

The Congressional Budget Office – not prone to scaremongering – projects the fiscal cliff would cause the economy to shrink by nearly 4 percent in the first quarter of 2013, enough to cause a double-dip recession.

4. Going over the fiscal cliff will make it easier to get a “grand bargain” on debt reduction.

Some political strategists argue that going over the cliff could turn up the pressure on deficit reduction and make it easier to reach a consensus. This logic goes: Once the tax cuts have expired, Congress can start from a different budget baseline, so that what would have been a tax increase on Dec. 31 will be a tax cut as of Jan. 1. I tried this logic on my 8-year-old son, who said: “Seriously, Mom? That is the dumbest thing I have heard.”

We are going to have to make some hard choices to fix not just the cliff but our broader budget problems. For Republicans, that means reforming the tax code in a way that would raise more revenue. And for Democrats, it means embracing structural entitlement reform, with strong protections for the most vulnerable. Waiting for a new baseline doesn’t make this easier, but it does put the country at tremendous risk.

And the idea that it would be easier to get a bipartisan compromise after going over the fiscal cliff completely misjudges how bad the blame game would be at that point. Politicians might think they would work it out quickly, but that’s a dangerous gamble.

5. Going over the fiscal cliff would be the worst possible outcome.

All the attention the fiscal cliff gets from lawmakers, businesses, experts and journalists can crowd out the key message. The looming cliff is an opportunity to make real progress on addressing the central, long-term fiscal challenge facing the United States: debt as a ballooning share of the economy.

There’s no doubt that going over the cliff would impose serious economic costs. But even worse would be blundering along without change. Our national debt threatens much larger consequences than those posed by the fiscal cliff. Rising debt could substantially hold back growth and send the country into a fiscal crisis that would be far worse than even a double-dip recession.

Among all the myths about the fiscal cliff, there is a certain truth. We will have to make changes to our fiscal course – either on our own terms or when the markets force us to. We should choose the first path.

Maya MacGuineas is the president of the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget. She wrote this for the Washington Post.

Advertisement