You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to www.journalgazette.net/newsletter and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.

Editorials

  • Environmental fixes out there in the ozone
    Anyone who has started a new exercise routine knows you need a mix of motivation to keep it up. You need mostly positive reinforcement but also a bit of negative reinforcement as well.
  • Real men help, not hit, their loved ones
    I am an expert on the topic of domestic violence; I grew up with it.As little children, my brothers and sisters and I grew up watching our dad hit our mother.
  • Money matters
     As The Journal Gazette’s Niki Kelly reported Sunday, Gov. Mike Pence has asked state agencies to plan 3 percent cuts in budgets they submit next year for 2016 and 2017.
Advertisement
Editorial

A promise reconsidered

Nearly two months before Gov.-elect Mike Pence takes office, legislative leaders from his own party have already expressed reservations about his campaign pledge to give Hoosiers a 10 percent cut on state income taxes.

At a legislative preview conference last week, Senate President Pro Tem David Long expressed caution about the tax cut, which would cost $500 million. He noted that lawmakers already have to decide how to make up for a phased reduction of the state corporate income tax and phased elimination of the state inheritance tax. Gambling revenue also is down.

House Speaker Brian Bosma was even more doubtful, noting that the previous balance between sales and income taxes already is out of whack, suggesting the state relies too much on sales taxes. An income tax cut would only exacerbate the imbalance.

Hoosiers have other reasons not to be optimistic about a state income tax cut. A $500 million tax cut would have to be accompanied by a spending cut of an equal or nearly equal amount after state government has already slashed state spending to the detriment of the most vulnerable Hoosiers. And some lawmakers rightly advocate for new spending on preschool education, an area where Indiana sorely lags other states.

Pence’s proposal also must be put into perspective.

A 10 percent cut of Indiana’s income tax rate of 3.4 percent would be just over one-third of 1 percent. For a household making the average income of about $35,000, that would be a cut of just $2.29 a week.

Certainly, any tax cut is often welcome. But Hoosier lawmakers in the past have failed to save surplus revenue when times were good, only to find the state coffers short when the economy slipped. Perhaps Pence’s administration and lawmakers will find a way to make such a cut work. But a campaign promise that butts up against contrary reality is one that should not be kept. And Pence’s promise appears to be contrary to the state’s best interests.

Advertisement