As the Fox alternate-universe drama Fringe ends its five-season run, let us pause to praise John Nobles textured performance as Walter Bishop – and his talented portrayals of Walter Bishop, Walter Bishop and Walter Bishop. And Anna Torv? Her work as Olivia Dunham, Olivia Dunham and Olivia Dunham has built a one-dimensional character into a genuine, multifaceted sci-fi heroine.
This is the situation in which Fringe fans find themselves ahead of the final, two-hour conclusion that airs tonight. So what on Earth – or, given that its Fringe, what on Earths – are we talking about here?
Only the fact that, unlike any other show in recent memory – or, perhaps, in television history itself – Fringe has required something of its troupe of actors that is both daunting and utterly captivating to watch: It forced them to play several different versions of their characters, sometimes all at once, and define unique characteristics and emotional memories for each one over time.
This has been the case since the first season, which introduced the notion of multiple universes with a finale called Theres More Than One of Everything. By and by, the multiplicity produced dialogue you wouldnt find anywhere else, like the time when Nobles Walter Bishop says to Jasika Nicoles Agent Astrid Farnsworth: Youre not you, are you?
For the past five seasons, Fringe has chronicled the exploits of Olivia, forced to collaborate with licorice-chomping, soft-hearted, guilt-ridden mad scientist Dr. Bishop to explore fringe events, weird occurrences that suggest a nefarious plan is afoot to threaten the world. Joining them is Walters adult son Peter (Joshua Jackson), who has played a special role in all thats unfolding.
Jackson, though, ended up the only main character in the show who wasnt regularly playing different versions of himself.
Fringe was an unusual acting challenge for sure, largely because of its slow burn. The show has spent five seasons engineering crossovers to alternate universes, rebooting universes entirely and generally exploiting the entertainment potential of quantum theory to produce slight variations on characters who were subtly different based on the experiences their circumstances forced them to endure.
Thus Blair Brown has played her character, Nina Sharp, as a frosty tycoon, a mysterious ally and even a maternal figure to a main character. Seth Gabel developed two versions of Agent Lincoln Lee in two separate universes – one quiet, earnest and slightly shy, the other gregarious, trash-talking and militaristic.
Fringe Divisions leader, Phillip Broyles (Lance Reddick), is a supervising agent in one reality and a colonel in another – kind but cold in the first, cold but kind in the second. And in one universe, Agent Farnsworth is a smiling, empathetic foil to Walter Bishop; in another, shes colder, numbers-focused and shows signs of Aspergers.
But the most fascinating permutations of this have come from Torv and Noble, who play two of the three main characters around whom the shows own universe spins.
Torvs initial Olivia Dunham was reserved, emotionally stunted, unwilling to trust or commit – based partially on her experiences with an abusive stepfather. The alternate-universe Fauxlivia was tougher, more disciplined – and more outgoing and willing to take what is hers. And the Olivia of later seasons, a hybrid of the original and a third one, is still reserved but able to access her feelings more readily. (In one story, Torv even portrayed a version of herself as possessed by Leonard Nimoys consciousness. Dont ask.)
Nobles performances, though, have been the shows tour de force. He has played Dr. Walter Bishop as an addled old man, a misguided genius, a ruthless technocrat and a combination of all three – plus a younger version of himselves.
Whats more, he played Walternate, the alternate-universe defense secretary whose motives are shadowy but whose methods are downright cruel. Some of the shows most electric moments unfolded when Noble shared screen time with himself – not because of the differences in the characters but because of their similarities even under very different circumstances.
And thats the point, really.
Science fiction though it is, Fringe has always been about universal themes: family, responsibility to community and, in the end, how our experiences shape our identities. Because even in our own universe, arent we all different people – each of us, every day, calibrating our identities slightly to fit an ever more complex web of moments and interactions? Thats what Fringe did. It examined how to be a father when youre also a scientist, how to be human when youre also very alien, how to be a parent when youre also a child. Just like us, though we dont have doppelgangers in alternate universes to compare ourselves to.