You choose, we deliver
If you are interested in this story, you might be interested in others from The Journal Gazette. Go to and pick the subjects you care most about. We'll deliver your customized daily news report at 3 a.m. Fort Wayne time, right to your email.
Associated Press

Object lesson

So, now the nightmare scenario is not just a scenario.

Now we get the grim sight of standout Kentucky freshman Nerlens Noel -- who surely would be drawing an NBA paycheck now were it not for the league's ridiculous age-limit rule -- being helped off the floor last night after tearing his ACL in a loss to Florida. He's lost for the season, lending a whole new meaning to the phrase "one-and-done."

A shot-blocking big man coming off a blown knee, after all, does not have nearly the draft appeal of a shot-blocking big man with two healthy knees. Which is what Noel was coming into this season.

If NBA rules allowed him to play right out of high school -- which, it says here, anyone who's good enough should be able to do -- he'd at least be earning a living doing what his gift allows him to do. Instead, forced to spend this year as one of John Calipari's rentals, he's likely looking at a diminished draft status, which the means the living he'd have earned will be diminished, too.

Bottom line: The NBA's rule punishes the truly gifted. And at the same time, it punishes college basketball, too, reducing it to little more than a weigh station for kids who are required to participate in an obvious charade not of their making.

It's bad (and, as Noel demonstrates, potentially costly) for the one-and-dones. And it's bad for college basketball.

Time to do something about it, David Stern.

Ben Smith's blog.