The void youre looking at on your DVR is the sitcom landscape post-30 Rock.
When Tina Feys bright, bouncy, irreverent showbiz send-up aired its last episode last month, a light (Kenneths toothy grin?) went out in broadcast television.
30 Rock was not perfect: It sometimes spun its wheels and its writing was often too showy. But 30 Rock was the clear sitcom heir to Seinfeld, pushing comedy forward by fusing the relationship set-up of The Mary Tyler Moore Show with the flashback jump-cutting of the single-camera Arrested Development. Its snappy, joke-packed universe was both tightly controlled and capable of going anywhere – a fiction funhouse version of Feys Weekend Update social satire. Oh, and it had Alec Baldwin.
With 30 Rock leaving the air, the sitcom again finds itself at a crossroads. Though acclaimed and award-winning, 30 Rock was never highly rated. Sitcom fans and creators alike can reasonably wonder that if such a show as 30 Rock had trouble finding viewers, what chance do other quality sitcoms have?
At least since the resolutely cynical Seinfeld and the absurdist (and underrated) NewsRadio, the sitcom has been self-reflexive, a parody of itself. Laugh tracks and simple sets before studio audiences gave way to wider-ranging single-camera freedom. But aside from 30 Rock and Arrested Development, this has led to little more than better decorated interiors.
Many would say ABCs Modern Family is the strongest current sitcom, but, like many comedies today, its better at being charming and heartwarming than funny in a fresh way. The same issue has crept into NBCs Parks and Recreation, the likable small-town government sitcom from Feys cohort Amy Poehler. Sliding into a rut has never been a problem for another NBC comedy, Community. It has madcap inventiveness going for it, but not much else.
The end of 30 Rock heralds a sitcom shift, particularly in NBCs long-running Thursday night block – a tradition since Seinfeld. Both Park and Recreation and Community have cloudy futures, and the long-running The Office will finally end soon. Elsewhere, CBSs How I Met Your Mother, a studio audience vestige, is preparing its final season.
But there are actually quite a lot of broadcast sitcoms running now, including The Big Bang Theory, Whitney, Happy Endings, 2 Broke Girls, The Mindy Project and the recently premiered and somewhat promising White House farce 1600 Penn.
Two Fox shows in their second seasons appear to have hit their stride: the animated Bobs Burgers and Zooey Deschanels New Girl. Bobs Burgers, created by many of those involved with the improvised 1990s Comedy Central series Dr. Katz, Professional Therapist, has coalesced into the funniest family portrait on TV. H. Jon Benjamin voices a fry cook, and comedians Kristen Schaal and Eugene Mirman, as two of his adolescent kids, steal the show.
New Girl, easily dismissed at first as cloying hipsterism, has also found a balance, thanks partly to the excellent Jake Johnson, whose chemistry with Deschanel is, for better or worse, TVs new Ross-Rachel.
Whatever the value of the shows, its a great time for individual comedic performances: Rainn Wilson on The Office; Julia-Louis Dreyfus on Veep; Chris Pratt on Parks; Neil Patrick Harris on How I Met Your Mother; Julie Bowen on Modern Family.
The flight to cable hasnt been as pronounced in sitcoms as it has been in hour-long dramas, but the trend is going that way. On cable, niche sitcoms like Its Always Sunny in Philadelphia, The League and Archer have pushed the boundaries of taste, reveling in their freedom.
But there are only two must-watch comedies on TV now that 30 Rock is over. Both are on cable and both draw more from independent film than from sitcom history: Louis C.K.s Louie (currently on hiatus for FX) and Lena Dunhams Girls on HBO (maybe youve heard a thing or two about it).
A comedian interested in a TV series now is less likely to strive for the large broadcast audience of 30 Rock than follow in the personal storytelling of Dunham and C.K. (C.K., after all, already tried updating the sitcom with Lucky Louie, which kept the traditional multi-camera, studio audience formula but built episodes around real adult problems and mature jokes. It lasted one season on HBO.)
The most anticipated upcoming sitcom premiere isnt on broadcast or even cable. Netflix will debut a new season of Arrested Development in May, years after it was canceled on Fox. Sitcom nostalgia may already be in full swing.