NEW YORK – Home décor and food guru Martha Stewart testified in court on Tuesday that she did nothing wrong when she signed an agreement to open shops within most of J.C. Penneys stores across the country.
Stewart testified in New York state court in a trial over whether the company she founded breached its contract to sell cookware, bedding and other items exclusively at Macys when she inked the deal with Penney.
During three hours of testimony, Stewart, who founded Martha Stewart Living Omnimedia Inc., denied Macys allegations that she did anything unethical and said she was only looking to expand her brand.
In fact, Stewart said its Macys that didnt uphold its end of the agreement to try to maximize the potential of her business. She said her brand had grown to about $300 million at Macys, but the business was now static at the department store chain. She said she had hoped the business would exceed $400 million.
We were disappointed, Stewart, 71, wearing a light brown tunic and a miniskirt, testified. We got to a certain dollar amount and struggled and never got any further.
The trial, which began Feb. 20, focuses on whether Macys has the exclusive right to sell some Martha Stewart branded products such as cookware, bedding and bath items.
Penney signed a pact in December 2011 with Martha Stewart Living to open shops at most of its 1,100 stores by this spring. A month later, Macys renewed its long-standing exclusive deal with Martha Stewart until 2018, then it sued both Martha Stewart Living and Penney.
Macys is trying to block Penneys from opening the shops. The company also is seeking to stop Martha Stewart from providing any designs to Penney – whether or not they carry the Martha Stewart label.
Martha Stewart and Penney are using what they believe is a loophole in the agreement between Macys and Martha Stewart to move forward with their deal. Its a provision that allows Martha Stewart to sell some of the products that it offers in Macys stores at Martha Stewart stores, too.
According to Martha Stewart lawyers, because the Macys agreement doesnt specify that Martha Stewart stores have to be stand alone stores, the mini shops within Penneys stores would not violate the contract. Stewart said in court Tuesday that even Amazon.com could be considered a store, given that shoppers are shifting more to online buying.
I dont think you need walls to be a store, she said.