The Journal Gazette
Tuesday, September 15, 2020 1:00 am

Asian Americans' allegiance deepening

John A. Tures

Asian Americans used to be a reliable Republican voting bloc. But long before Kamala Harris, who is Indian American and Black, became Joe Biden's running mate, they shifted to support the Democratic Party. This is true across ages, genders and ethnic origins of Asian Americans – including Indian, Chinese, Filipino, Japanese, Korean, Vietnamese and Hmong.

As a political scientist, I'm not just interested in voting, but also in how groups change their party preferences. This subject of study, known as “critical elections,” looks at how political party fortunes change over time as a result of racial, religious or regional groups' changing views.

In 1992, the New York Times added the Asian American demographic to its exit polls. In that election, Asian Americans preferred incumbent Republican President George H.W. Bush to Arkansas Gov. Bill Clinton, a Democrat, by 24 percentage points – 55% to 31%. (Independent H. Ross Perot got 15% of the Asian American vote, and Clinton won.)

Four years later, 48% of Asian Americans supported Republican Bob Dole, and 43% supported Clinton – just a five-point Republican advantage.

Then, in 2000, Democrat Al Gore received 54% of the Asian American vote, against 41% for Republican George W. Bush, the son of the man who had won a strong majority of the group's vote just eight years earlier.

The trend continued in 2004 as 56% of Asian Americans backed Democrat John Kerry and in 2008 with a whopping 62%-35% advantage to Barack Obama in those New York Times exit polls.

More recently, CNN's exit polls showed a 73%-26% split in favor of Obama over former Gov. Mitt Romney of Massachusetts in 2012, and a 65%-27% preference for Hillary Clinton over Donald Trump in 2016.

Preliminary data from late August 2020 polls shows Biden leading comfortably among Asian Americans as well.

Since 2000, the Asian American population has climbed 87%, now exceeding 22 million. In that same period, the number of Asian Americans eligible to vote has more than doubled, making it the fastest-growing racial or ethnic group in the electorate.

It's true that Asian Americans are not necessarily a homogeneous group. Some have wondered whether those with ties to countries that experienced communist rule might be more supportive of the Republican Party.

Research by Catalina Huamei Huang delves into these details, using data from the National Asian American Survey.

She finds that all but one of the groups included in the survey's fall 2016 poll have an unfavorable assessment of the Republican Party. Cambodian Americans are split on the subject, with just under half disliking the party and a similar percentage liking it. In most groups – except Filipinos, Cambodians and Hmong – fewer than a third view the Republican Party favorably.

By contrast, in the same study, more than two-thirds of Hmong, Japanese and Indians view the Democratic Party favorably. Vietnamese and Cambodians are the only groups with fewer than half of their members who view the Democratic Party favorably. As Huang found, those numbers are similar to results in a spring 2016 survey by the civil rights group Asian Americans Advancing Justice.

Huang's analysis of both surveys also showed that Asian Americans of all ages are likely to be critical of Republicans. Younger people are more likely to be critical. All ages are also more likely to perceive the Democratic Party favorably, especially those younger than 35.

Asian American men and women prefer the Democratic Party by wide margins, and think less well of the GOP.

Those demographic splits were also supported by Asian Americans' assessments of the 2016 presidential candidates, Trump and Clinton, in both polls, with the exception of Vietnamese Americans, who were divided. In 2020, Asian Americans are, if anything, more negative about Trump than they are toward his party. With Biden's choice of Harris as a running mate, Asian Americans of all backgrounds may further solidify their support for the Democratic Party.

John A. Tures is a professor of political science at LaGrange College in Georgia.

Share this article

Email story

Subscribe to our newsletters

* indicates required